Jeremiah 5
About this chapter
The chapter (checked in the WLC (WLC)). A sequence of short poems on the corruption of Jerusalem and the coming invader:
- Jer 5:1–6: the search for one just man. Roam the streets of Jerusalem: if there is one who does justice, Yahweh will forgive the city; the poor do not know the way of Yahweh, and the great have broken the yoke; lion, wolf and leopard wait for them.
- Jer 5:7–9: adultery and the refrain. Fed full, they committed adultery; "Shall I not punish for these things?… shall I not avenge myself?"
- Jer 5:10–19: the vineyard stripped; the people's denial ("Not he!"); the nation from afar. Yahweh's words in the prophet's mouth become fire; a nation of an unknown language will eat everything; yet "I will not make a full end" (5:18), and the exile is explained in prose (5:19).
- Jer 5:20–31: a people without a heart. The sea keeps its boundary, but the people do not; they do not say "Let us revere Yahweh, who gives the rain"; the wicked trap people and grow fat; the refrain again; "the prophets prophesy falsely… and my people love it so."
The refrain Jer 5:9 = Jer 5:29 (and Jer 9:8, in jer-009) marks the structure (checked) [Widely held]. The speakers are Yahweh and the prophet (5:3–5, the prophet's search) (D-1403). The Masoretic section marks fall after 5:9, 5:13, 5:19 and 5:29 (setumah) (checked).
Layout (D-109b; D-1403). Verse except Jer 5:18–19, a prose comment with a question-and-answer form like Jer 16:10–13 and Deut 29:23–27 (checked). Lines are divided at atnaḥ, zaqef, revia' and segolta (checked). Jer 5:2, Jer 5:16 and Jer 5:30 are short two-line verses; Jer 5:30 has no atnaḥ and runs on into Jer 5:31.
Repetitions kept (Charter §5.6; checked): the refrain (Jer 5:9; Jer 5:29); "justice" (mishpat, Jer 5:1; Jer 5:4–5; Jer 5:28); "honesty" (emunah, Jer 5:1; Jer 5:3; D-1927); "refuse" (me'en, Jer 5:3 twice); "the way of Yahweh, the justice of their God" (Jer 5:4–5); "full end" (kalah, Jer 5:10; Jer 5:18; as Jer 4:27); "eat" (akhal, four times in Jer 5:17, with Jer 5:14); "cross" ('avar, Jer 5:22 twice; Jer 5:28 "passed beyond"); "abandon" (Jer 5:7; Jer 5:19); "serve" (Jer 5:19 twice); "revere" (yare', Jer 5:22; Jer 5:24; D-180).
Ketiv and qere (D-1294; checked in the OSHB markup). Jer 5:6 (spelling of "turnings-away"), Jer 5:7 (spelling of "forgive"), Jer 5:24 ("and the early rain" / "the early rain"). None affects the meaning; the qere is followed.
The Greek (D-2361). No Greek reading is reported in this unit beyond the text notes at 5:7 and 5:13 (needs-edition).
Verse numbering. Hebrew and English agree.
18"But even in those days — oracle of Yahweh — I will not make a full end of you.15 וְגַ֛ם בַּיָּמִ֥ים הָהֵ֖מָּה נְאֻם־יְהֹוָ֑ה לֹֽא־אֶעֱשֶׂ֥ה אִתְּכֶ֖ם כָּלָֽה׃ 19And when you say, 'Why has Yahweh our God done all these things to us?' you shall say to them, 'As you abandoned me and served foreign gods in your land, so you will serve strangers in a land that is not yours.'" וְהָיָה֙ כִּ֣י תֹאמְר֔וּ תַּ֣חַת מֶ֗ה עָשָׂ֨ה יְהֹוָ֧ה אֱלֹהֵ֛ינוּ לָ֖נוּ אֶת־כָּל־אֵ֑לֶּה וְאָמַרְתָּ֣ אֲלֵיהֶ֗ם כַּאֲשֶׁ֨ר עֲזַבְתֶּ֤ם אוֹתִי֙ וַתַּעַבְד֞וּ אֱלֹהֵ֤י נֵכָר֙ בְּאַרְצְכֶ֔ם כֵּ֚ן תַּעַבְד֣וּ זָרִ֔ים בְּאֶ֖רֶץ לֹ֥א לָכֶֽם׃ ס
Notes
Emunah "steadiness, reliability, honesty" (OSHB 530; checked (WLC)). In Jeremiah it is a quality of speech and dealing (Jer 5:3; Jer 7:28, "emunah has perished, it is cut off from their mouth"; Jer 9:2) (checked). ReScript renders it "honesty" in these chapters (D-1927), to keep it apart from emet "faithfulness" (D-198), which the book also uses (Jer 4:2; Jer 9:4). We-eslaḥ lah "that I may forgive her" (salaḥ, D-1305; God only): the city personified. The search recalls Abraham's bargaining for Sodom (Gen 18:23–32).
La-kein la-sheqer yishshave'u, Lit "therefore (surely) to falsehood they swear" (checked (WLC); D-1397). Lakhen "therefore" is here asseverative or adversative ("yet, surely"). The oath "As Yahweh lives" is required in Jer 4:2; here it is used falsely.
The prophet addresses Yahweh. Killitam "you finished them off" (kalah piel, "bring to an end") is hyperbole for crushing blows that did not bring them back. Lo ḥalu "they felt no pain" (ḥil / ḥul, "writhe"; the same verb as "tremble" in Jer 5:22) (checked (WLC)). Me'anu lashuv "they refused to return" (shuv, D-2362), as me'anu qaḥat musar "they refused to take discipline": the repeated "refused" is kept.
Dallim "the poor, the weak," the uneducated who might be excused; no'alu "they act foolishly" (ya'al, niphal; OSHB 2973). Ha-gedolim "the great ones" are the leading men, who should know derekh YHWH mishpat Eloheihem, "the way of Yahweh, the justice of their God," that is, what God requires (mishpat as the right order or custom he lays down) [Widely held]. The two clauses are repeated word for word in Jer 5:4 and Jer 5:5 (checked).
Shoqed "keeping watch," the verb of Jer 1:12 ("I am watching over my word"; checked (WLC)): the animal lying in wait outside the towns. Ze'ev 'aravot "a wolf of the deserts" (or "of the evenings," vocalizing 'aravot as "evenings," as Hab 1:8; Zeph 3:3 "evening wolves") [Debated; Unverified]. Ketiv and qere (D-1294): ketiv mshbwtyhm, qere meshuvoteihem (spelling only; checked). Pish'eihem "their rebellions" (pesha'), meshuvoteihem "their turnings-away" (D-2362).
Wa-asbi'a otam "and I satisfied them" (sava', hiphil; checked (WLC)). A different vocalization or a one-letter difference, wa-ashbi'a "and I made them swear" (shava', hiphil), would continue "sworn by what are no gods," and some Hebrew manuscripts and versions are reported to read so (Unverified; not read in an edition) [Debated]. The Masoretic reading fits the theme of prosperity leading to unfaithfulness (Deut 32:15; Hos 13:6) and is kept. Wa-yin'afu "they committed adultery" (na'af) and beit zonah "the house of a prostitute" are rendered plainly (D-2366; D-116); whether literal adultery or the worship of other gods is meant, the next verse (the neighbor's wife) shows that literal adultery is at least included [Debated]. Yitgodadu is either "they trooped, thronged" (from gedud "band") or "they gashed themselves" (as in mourning rites, Jer 16:6; Jer 41:5; OSHB 1413) [Debated]. Ketiv and qere (D-1294): ketiv 'slwḥ, qere eslaḥ "I forgive" (spelling only; checked). Be-lo elohim "by no-gods," Lit "by not-god."
Lit "Horses meyuzzanim maskim they were" (checked (WLC)). Both words are uncertain. Meyuzzanim is usually taken from zun "feed" ("well-fed"); maskim is taken as "rising early" (from shakham), or, with a different root, "with heavy testicles" (from a root 'shk "testicle," compare 'eshekh in Lev 21:20), so "lusty" [Debated; Unverified in a lexicon]. "Well-fed, lusty" gives the sense the image requires: each "neighs" (yitshalu) after his neighbor's wife. The image is rendered plainly (D-116), as is Ezekiel's (Ezek 23:20).
The refrain (Jer 5:9; Jer 5:29; Jer 9:8). Lit "Shall I not attend (efqod) upon these things — oracle of Yahweh — and on a nation such as this shall my self (nafshi) not avenge itself?" (checked (WLC)). Paqad 'al is "punish for" (Q-213, paqad "attend to"). Here and in 5:29 the Hebrew has no object ("for these things"); Jer 9:8 adds bam "them" ("Shall I not punish them for these things?" in jer-009), and the English shows the difference (Charter §5.6; D-1929). 5:9 has we-im "and," 5:29 im without "and"; the English is the same. Titnaqqem nafshi: nefesh as the self (nephesh.md), "I avenge myself."
Sharoteha (only here; OSHB 8284) is uncertain: "her vine rows" or "her walls (terraces)" [Debated; Unverified]. Netishoteha "her tendrils, shoots" (also Isa 18:5). The vineyard is Israel (Jer 2:21). "But do not make a full end" stands in the same tension as Jer 4:27 (see the note there).
Lo hu' "Not he!" (checked (WLC)): "he will do nothing," or "he is not (God)," or "it is not he (who speaks through the prophets)" [Debated]. Kept as short as the Hebrew. Kiḥḥashu ba-YHWH "they have denied Yahweh," Lit "they have lied against Yahweh." "Sword and famine" is the shorter form of the book's triad (D-1399).
We-ha-dibber ein bahem (checked (WLC)): dibber is vocalized as a noun "the word, the speaking" (OSHB 1699; only here in this form). Some revocalize ha-dabber "the speaker" or read ha-davar "the word" [Debated; Unverified]. The Greek is reported to read "and the word of the Lord was not in them" (Unverified; not read in an edition). The speakers of 5:13 may be the people (mocking the prophets as "wind," ruaḥ, a pun on the prophetic spirit) or Yahweh (announcing the fate of the prophets who promise peace) [Debated]; the last clause "so let it be done to them" fits the people's curse on the prophets. Speakers are not labeled (D-1403).
The address shifts: "Because you (plural) have spoken this word" (the people's "Not he!" of 5:12) — "I am making my words in your (singular) mouth a fire": the prophet's (checked (WLC)). The promise of Jer 1:9 ("I have put my words in your mouth") becomes a threat. YHWH Elohei tseva'ot "Yahweh, the God of armies" (D-1311).
The description follows the covenant curse of Deut 28:49–52 (a nation "from afar… whose language you do not understand," eating the produce, besieging the fortified towns; checked). Eitan "enduring, perennial" (like a stream that does not dry up) and me-'olam "from of old" fit Babylon's ancient civilization [Widely held; the identification Unverified]; the language would be Akkadian or Aramaic.
Akhal "eat" four times, with the subject changing from singular "it" (the nation) to plural "they" in the second line (checked (WLC)); the English keeps the change. Yeroshesh "it will beat down, shatter" (rashash, OSHB 7567). The address is now masculine singular ("your harvest… in which you trust").
The prose verses 5:18–19 limit the judgment just announced and explain the exile in catechism form ("When you say, Why…? you shall say…"), like Jer 16:10–13 and Deut 29:23–27 (checked). Many hold that they are an exilic addition in the style of the prose sermons [Debated; Unverified]. The tension with 5:17 is kept (Charter §7). Elohei nekhar "foreign gods" (nekhar "foreignness"; compare nokhri "foreigner," D-1297) and zarim "strangers" (D-1928): the people who served foreign gods in their own land will serve foreigners in a foreign land.
Ha-oti lo tira'u "Do you not revere me?" (yare' with God as object, D-180), in parallel with lo taḥilu "do you not tremble" (checked (WLC)). The parallel shows that the "fear" includes fright before the Creator's power; "revere" is kept by D-180, and the parallel line gives the trembling. The same verb returns in the people's unspoken "Let us revere Yahweh" (Jer 5:24). The sea held by a boundary of sand is a creation image (Job 38:8–11; Ps 104:9; checked).
Lev sorer u-moreh: the pair of Deut 21:18, ben sorer u-moreh "a stubborn and defiant son," whom the law punishes by death (checked (WLC)). Marah "defy" as in Jer 4:17. Saru "they have turned aside" plays on sorer "stubborn" (both s-r). Unlike the sea, the people do not stay within the bounds.
Yoreh "the early rain" (October–November) and malqosh "the late rain" (March–April) (note at Jer 3:3) [Widely held]. Shevu'ot ḥuqqot qatsir "the weeks fixed for the harvest," the seven weeks between barley and wheat harvest (compare Deut 16:9) [Widely held]. Ketiv and qere (D-1294): ketiv w-yrh "and the early rain," qere yoreh (checked in the OSHB markup); the qere is followed.
'Avonoteikhem "your guilty deeds" (plural of 'avon, D-138: here the wrong acts that bring guilt) and ḥatto'teikhem "your wrongdoings" (D-139). "These" are the rains and harvests of 5:24.
Lit "he watches (yashur) like the crouching (shakh) of fowlers" (checked (WLC)). The singular verb, the rare shakh (only here; OSHB 7918) and the syntax are difficult, and emendations have been proposed [Debated; Unverified]. The sense is clear from 5:26b–27: the wicked trap people as bird-catchers trap birds, and fill their houses with the gains of deceit as a cage is filled with birds. Mashḥit "trap," Lit "destroyer." Anashim "human beings," Lit "men."
Lit "they have also crossed over ('averu) words / matters of evil" (checked (WLC)): either "they surpass (all) in evil deeds" or "they overlook evil deeds" (pass over them, do not punish) [Debated]. 'Ashtu "they are sleek" (only here as a verb; OSHB 6245) [Unverified]. Din lo danu din yatom we-yatsliḥu is Lit "a case they do not judge, the case of the fatherless, and they prosper" or "that they (the fatherless) might prosper"; the English takes it as "so as to make it succeed" [Debated]. U-mishpat evyonim lo shafatu "and the right of the needy they do not defend (judge)." The crossing of bounds in 5:28 echoes the sea that does not cross its boundary (Jer 5:22, 'avar).
Lit "and the priests rule upon their hands" (yirdu 'al yedeihem, checked (WLC)): "at their (the prophets') direction" or "by their own authority" [Debated]; radah "rule" (OSHB 7287; compare D-144). Some derive the verb from radah "scrape out" ("the priests scrape (profits) into their hands") [Debated; Unverified]. Nibbe'u va-sheqer "prophesy falsely," Lit "prophesy by falsehood" (D-1397). U-mah ta'asu le-aḥaritah "and what will you do at its end?": the end of this state of affairs, or of the city.
Cross-references
- 1 Gen 18:32 Abraham bargains for Sodom down to ten upright people; here not even one is found.
- 1 Ezek 22:30 'I looked for a man among them… but I found none'.
- 1 Ps 14:3 'There is no one who does good, not even one'.
- 1 ← Jer 7:28 'If there is anyone… who seeks honesty'.
- 1 ← Mic 7:2 'See if you can find a man, one who does justice and seeks faithfulness'.
- 2 Jer 4:2 'Swear, As Yahweh lives, in faithfulness, in justice and in uprightness'.
- 2 Jer 7:9 'Swear falsely' among the commandments broken.
- 2 ← Isa 48:1 'Though they say, As Yahweh lives, yet they swear falsely'.
- 3 Jer 2:30 'In vain I struck your children; they took no discipline'.
- 3 Ezek 3:9 'Like diamond, harder than flint, I have made your forehead'.
- 3 ← Jer 8:5 'They refused to return'.
- 4 ← Jer 8:7 'They do not know the way of Yahweh, the justice of their God'.
- 4 ← Mic 3:1 The poor 'do not know the way of Yahweh, the justice of their God'; the great should know it.
- 5 Jer 2:20 'Long ago I broke your yoke, I tore off your bonds': the same words, there of Yahweh (Masoretic vowels).
- 5 Ps 2:3 'Let us tear off their bonds, and throw their ropes off us'.
- 6 Hos 13:7 'I will be to them like a lion; like a leopard I will keep watch (ashur) by the way'.
- 6 Hab 1:8 The Chaldeans' horses 'are fiercer than the wolves of the evening'.
- 6 Jer 1:12 Shoqed, 'watching': the same verb as Yahweh's watching over his word.
- 7 Deut 32:15 'Jeshurun grew fat and kicked… and he abandoned the God who made him'.
- 7 Hos 13:6 'When they were fed, they were full… therefore they forgot me'.
- 7 Jer 2:11 'Has a nation exchanged gods, when they are no gods?'
- 8 Ezek 23:20 Oholibah lusted after lovers 'whose issue was like the issue of horses'.
- 8 Jer 13:27 'Your adulteries and your neighings, the lewdness of your prostitution'.
- 8 Exod 20:17 'You shall not covet your neighbor's wife'.
- 9 Jer 5:29 The refrain repeated word for word.
- 9 Jer 9:8 The refrain a third time, with 'them' (bam) added.
- 9 ← Isa 57:6 'Shall I not punish for these things?': the same rhetorical question of judgment.
- 10 Jer 2:21 Israel, the choice vine become the wild shoots of a foreign vine.
- 10 Jer 4:27 'Yet I will not make a full end'.
- 11 Jer 3:20 'As a woman is treacherous to her lover, so you have been treacherous to me'.
- 12 Zeph 1:12 Those who say in their heart, 'Yahweh will not do good, and he will not do harm'.
- 12 Jer 14:13 The prophets say, 'You will not see the sword, and you will not have famine'.
- 12 Ps 14:1 'The fool says in his heart, There is no God'.
- 12 ← Isa 59:13 'They have denied (kiḥashu) Yahweh and said, He is nothing'.
- 12 ← Jer 23:17 'No disaster will come upon us; we will not see sword or famine'.
- 14 Jer 1:9 'Look, I have put my words in your mouth'.
- 14 Jer 23:29 'Is not my word like fire — oracle of Yahweh — and like a hammer that shatters rock?'
- 14 Jer 20:9 The word 'like a burning fire shut up in my bones'.
- 14 ← Rev 11:5 ReScript 'look, I am making my words in your mouth a fire, and this people wood, and it will devour them'.
- 15 Deut 28:49 The covenant curse: 'Yahweh will bring a nation against you from afar… a nation whose language you do not understand'.
- 15 Isa 28:11 'With stammering lips and with a foreign tongue he will speak to this people'.
- 15 ← Hab 1:6 'I am bringing against you a nation from afar… an enduring nation it is, an ancient nation'.
- 16 Ps 5:10 'Their throat is an open grave' (Eng. 5:9).
- 17 Deut 28:51 The nation from afar 'will eat the fruit of your livestock and the fruit of your ground'.
- 17 Jer 3:24 'The Shameful Thing has devoured… their flocks and their herds, their sons and their daughters'.
- 18 Jer 4:27 'Yet I will not make a full end'.
- 19 Jer 16:10 'Why has Yahweh pronounced all this great disaster against us?… Because your fathers abandoned me'.
- 19 Deut 29:23 The nations ask why Yahweh has done this to the land, and are answered (Eng. 29:24).
- 19 Deut 28:64 'There you will serve other gods… in the lands where Yahweh scatters you'.
- 21 Isa 6:10 'Lest they see with their eyes and hear with their ears and understand with their heart'.
- 21 Ps 115:5 Of idols: 'they have eyes but do not see; they have ears but do not hear'.
- 21 Ezek 12:2 'Who have eyes to see but do not see, and ears to hear but do not hear'.
- 21 ← Deut 29:3 'Who have eyes but do not see, who have ears but do not hear'.
- 21 ← Isa 43:8 'Who have eyes but do not see, who have ears but do not hear'.
- 21 ← Jer 4:22 'Hear this, foolish people without a heart'.
- 21 ← Mark 8:18 ReScript: 'who have eyes but do not see, who have ears but do not hear'.
- 21 ← Matt 13:13 ReScript: 'who have eyes but do not see, who have ears but do not hear'.
- 22 Job 38:10 'I set my limit (ḥuqqi) for it and set bars and doors, and said, Thus far you shall come'.
- 22 Ps 104:9 'You set a boundary they may not cross, so that they will not return to cover the earth'.
- 22 Prov 8:29 'When he set for the sea its limit, so that the waters would not pass beyond his command'.
- 22 ← Job 14:5 Ḥoq, the 'limit' set for the sea, 'which it cannot pass'.
- 23 Deut 21:18 Ben sorer u-moreh, 'a stubborn and defiant son', whom the law condemns.
- 24 Deut 11:14 'I will give the rain of your land in its season, the early rain and the late rain'.
- 24 Jer 3:3 'The showers have been withheld, and the late rain has not come'.
- 24 Hos 2:10 'She did not know that it was I who gave her the grain, the new wine and the fresh oil' (Eng. 2:8).
- 24 ← Acts 14:17 ReScript 'Let us revere Yahweh our God, who gives the rain, the early rain and the late rain, in its season'.
- 24 ← Jas 5:7 ReScript 'who gives the rain, the early rain and the late rain, in its season'.
- 25 Isa 59:2 'Your guilty deeds have made a separation between you and your God'.
- 26 Ps 10:9 The wicked man 'lies in ambush in hiding, like a lion… to seize the afflicted'.
- 27 Amos 8:1 Another basket-and-cage image of the corrupt city's fullness.
- 28 Isa 1:23 'They do not judge the case of the fatherless, and the widow's lawsuit does not come before them'.
- 28 Jer 22:16 Josiah 'judged the cause of the poor and needy; then it was well'.
- 29 Jer 5:9 The refrain repeated word for word.
- 29 ← Jer 9:8 The refrain a second time.
- 30 Jer 23:14 'Among the prophets of Jerusalem I have seen a horrible thing (sha'arurah)'.
- 30 ← Hos 6:10 'A horrible thing (sha'ammah we-sha'arurah) has happened in the land'.
- 30 ← Jer 18:13 'A horror and a horrible thing (sha'arurah) has happened in the land'.
- 31 Jer 14:14 'The prophets are prophesying falsehood in my name'.
- 31 Mic 3:11 'Its priests teach for a price, and its prophets divine for silver'.
- 31 ← Luke 6:26 'the prophets prophesy falsely… and my people love it so'.