Psalms 58
About this chapter
The psalm (checked in the WLC (WLC)). An accusation against unjust judges, followed by curses and a promise that God judges.
- Ps 58:2–6: the accusation: "Do you indeed speak justice…? No, in heart you work injustices"; the wicked are estranged from the womb, like a deaf cobra that will not hear the charmer.
- Ps 58:7–10: the curses: "God, break their teeth in their mouth"; let them melt like water, like a snail, like a miscarriage.
- Ps 58:11–12: the outcome: the upright will rejoice when he sees vengeance; "Surely there is a God who judges on the earth."
Who is accused? (D-2465). Ps 58:2 addresses a group who "speak justice" and "judge human beings." The MT points elem "silence"; with other vowels the word is elim "gods" (as Exod 15:11, ba-elim; checked) or eilim "rulers, mighty ones." Read as elim, the psalm is a judgment on the gods of the nations, as in Ps 82:1–7 (checked), where God condemns the gods who "judge unjustly"; read with the MT, the addressees are human rulers or judges [Debated; Unverified]. The MT is translated; the case is listed for the owner (SIGNIFICANT).
The cry for vengeance (D-1422). The curses of 58:7–10 and the image of 58:11 ("he will wash his feet in the blood of the wicked") are translated plainly, as jussives and imperatives (see the note at 58:11).
The Elohistic Psalter (D-1419; see the note at Ps 42:2). YHWH once (58:7), Elohim twice (58:7, 12) (counted).
Layout (D-109b; D-1406; D-1423). Verse 1 is the heading, prose. The verses divide at atnaḥ into two lines; Ps 58:3 divides at 'oleh we-yored without atnaḥ (checked in the accent characters).
Repetitions kept (Charter §5.6; checked): "judge" (shafat, 58:2, 12); "the upright… the wicked" (58:4, 11, 12); "like" (kemo, seven times in 58:5–10); "venom" (ḥamat, 58:5 twice); "see" (ḥazah, 58:9, 11).
Ketiv and qere. Ps 58:8: ketiv ḥitso "his arrow," qere ḥitsav "his arrows"; the qere is followed (D-1294).
Verse numbering. The heading is verse 1, so the Hebrew verse numbers are one higher than the English throughout (Hebrew 58:2 = English 58:1; 58:12 = English 58:11) (VerseMap, checked).
1For the leader. According to "Do Not Destroy." Of David. A miktam.1 לַמְנַצֵּ֥חַ אַל־תַּשְׁחֵ֗ת לְדָוִ֥ד מִכְתָּֽם׃
Notes
The heading (checked (WLC)): lamenatseaḥ al-tashḥet le-David miktam, the same as the heading of Ps 57:1 without the historical note, and as Ps 59:1 before its note. See the note at Ps 57:1 on "Do Not Destroy." The OSHB tags al-tashḥet as a name (516).
SIGNIFICANT (D-2465; checked (WLC)). The MT reads ha-umnam elem tsedeq tedabberun, Lit "Truly — silence — justice you speak?" with elem "silence" (OSHB 482, as in the heading of Ps 56:1). The MT can be construed "Do you indeed speak justice in silence?" — that is, is your justice mute? — but the sense is strained [Widely held].
The repointing. With other vowels the consonants 'lm read elim "gods" (as Exod 15:11; Ps 29:1, benei elim; checked) or eilim "rams, mighty men, rulers" (Exod 15:15, "the chiefs of Moab"; checked). "Do you indeed speak justice, you gods? Do you judge human beings with what is right?" is the reading of many modern scholars [Widely held; Unverified: no commentary read]. It fits the second line, where benei adam "human beings" are the ones judged, and the parallel of Ps 82:1–7, where God judges the gods for unjust judgment (checked). Others read "rulers" (human judges called elim, the Traditional reading of Ps 82 as well) [Debated].
Decision: a vowel departure is allowed under D-1293 with rank 1–3 evidence; here the evidence is rank 2 (the psalm's own second line; Ps 82 in the same Elohistic collection). Because the reading changes who is addressed (gods or men) and touches the divine-council question of D-2374, the coordinator lists it for the owner (SIGNIFICANT) and translates the MT. If adopted, the line becomes "Do you indeed speak justice, you gods?" (D-102: "gods" for other gods).
"With what is right": meisharim, as in Ps 9:9 (psa-009, "what is right"; D-1342) (checked). "Human beings": benei adam, the object of "judge," or a vocative, "you human beings" [Debated] (D-1660).
"No": af, "even, indeed, on the contrary" (checked (WLC)). "Injustices": 'olot, plural of 'awlah (as Ps 43:1, "injustice"). "You weigh out": tefallesun, from pilles "weigh out, level" (the peles is a balance, Prov 16:11): they dispense violence as if it were justice weighed on scales [Widely held] (checked). "In the land": or "on the earth" (ba-arets), the scope of their judgment; elim "gods" in 58:2 would favor "on the earth."
"Estranged": zoru, from zur "be a stranger" (checked (WLC)): they have been strangers (to God, to the right) since birth. "From birth": Lit "from the belly" (mi-beten). The hyperbole is the same kind as Ps 51:7 (checked).
"Venom": ḥamat, "heat, rage, venom" (the same word as "wrath"; Deut 32:24, ḥamat zoḥalei 'afar "the venom of things that crawl in the dust"; checked (WLC)). "A snake": naḥash (D-122 renders it "the serpent" in Genesis 3; here the ordinary animal, "a snake"). "A deaf cobra": peten, probably the cobra, the snake of the charmers [Widely held; Unverified]. The cobra was thought to stop its ear so as not to hear the charm [Widely held: an ancient belief; Unverified]. "Charmers… one who casts spells with skill" (58:6): melaḥashim (whisperers, Jer 8:17; Eccl 10:11) and ḥover ḥavarim "binder of bindings," the spell-caster of Deut 18:11 (checked).
The curses begin (D-1422; checked (WLC)). The images change from the snake to the lion (kefirim "young lions"; maltte'ot "fangs, jaws," a rare word, transposed from mettalle'ot in Job 29:17; checked). The imperatives are addressed to God. "Yahweh": the only YHWH in the psalm (D-1419; D-101).
Meaning uncertain (D-1955; checked (WLC)). The MT reads yimma'asu khemo-mayim yithallekhu-lamo / yidrokh ḥitsav kemo yitmolalu. The first line is clear: "let them melt away (ma'as II, OSHB 3988 b, 'flow away') like water (that) runs off for itself." The second is not: Lit "he will tread (bend the bow for) his arrows; like (them) they are cut off." Darakh "tread" is used of bending a bow (Ps 7:13; Ps 11:2; checked); the subject may be the wicked (whose arrows are then blunted) or God [Debated]. Yitmolalu, a hithpoel of malal "wither, be cut off" (OSHB 4135 b), is rare [Unverified]. The English follows the Hebrew words as closely as English allows. Ketiv and qere: ketiv ḥitso "his arrow," qere ḥitsav "his arrows" (D-1294).
"Snail": shabbelul, only here (OSHB 7642; checked (WLC)); the snail was thought to dissolve as it leaves its slime trail [Widely held as the image; Unverified]. "Melts away": temes, only here, "melting, dissolving" (from masas) [Widely held; Unverified]. "A woman's stillbirth": nefel eshet, the stillborn child of a woman (Job 3:16; Eccl 6:3; checked); eshet is the construct of ishah "woman," an unusual form here [Debated]. "May they not see the sun": bal-ḥazu shamesh, a perfect with bal, "who have not seen the sun," taken as a wish in the series of curses [Debated].
One of the most obscure verses of the Psalter (D-1955; checked (WLC)). Word by word: be-terem "before," yavinu "they understand / perceive" (here "feel"), sirotekhem "your pots" (or "your thorns," sirim, the same consonants with another sense, Isa 34:13), atad "bramble, thorn," kemo-ḥai "like living (green)," kemo-ḥaron "like burning (wrath)," yis'arennu "he will sweep it away in a storm" (sa'ar, as Ps 50:3). The image is often taken as a cooking fire of thorns under pots, swept away by a storm before the pot even feels the heat — the sudden end of the wicked [Widely held as an interpretation; Unverified]. Many emendations are proposed [Debated]; none is adopted. The English follows the word order; the meaning is uncertain. "Your" (plural) addresses the wicked (or the judges of 58:2).
Vengeance (D-1422; checked (WLC)). Naqam "vengeance" in the Hebrew Bible is the restoration of justice by a legitimate authority, here God's, against those who have shed blood (compare Deut 32:35; Deut 32:43) [Widely held; Unverified]. The image of washing the feet in the blood of the wicked is that of the victor walking over the battlefield (Ps 68:24; checked). The verse is translated plainly (D-1422; Charter §2a.4). Later Jewish and Christian interpreters read such verses as the hope for God's justice rather than personal revenge, or refused them in prayer [Traditional; Unverified]. "The upright": tsaddiq (D-140).
Lit "surely there is God (Elohim), judging (shofetim, plural) on the earth" (checked (WLC)). The plural participle with Elohim also occurs with the God of Israel (Gen 20:13; Gen 35:7, plural verbs; checked), so "a God who judges" is the usual reading [Widely held]; with elim "gods" in 58:2, some read "there are gods who judge" in irony or contrast, or "there is a God who judges (the gods)" [Debated]. "Fruit for the upright": a reward. "Humankind will say": we-yomar adam (D-104a, collective); quotation marks follow the verb of saying (D-1424).
Cross-references
- 2 Ps 82:2 "How long will you judge unjustly and show favor to the wicked?": God's charge against the gods.
- 2 Exod 15:11 "Who is like you among the gods (ba-elim), Yahweh?": elim "gods", the repointing proposed here.
- 2 ← Isa 45:19 Tsedeq and meisharim in speech and judgment: 'Do you indeed speak justice…? Do you judge human beings with what is right?'
- 3 Isa 26:7 "The path of the upright is straight; you level (tefalles) the track of the upright": the same verb.
- 4 Ps 51:7 "In guilt I was brought forth."
- 4 Isa 48:8 "A rebel from the womb you were called."
- 5 Deut 32:33 "Their wine is the venom (ḥamat) of serpents, the cruel poison of cobras (petanim)."
- 5 Jer 8:17 "Snakes, adders, for which there is no charming."
- 5 ← Ps 140:4 'They have venom like the venom of a serpent'.
- 6 Eccl 10:11 "If the serpent bites before it is charmed, there is no gain for the charmer."
- 6 Deut 18:11 Ḥover ḥaver "one who casts spells" among the forbidden practices.
- 7 Ps 3:8 "You have broken the teeth of the wicked."
- 7 Job 4:10 "The teeth of the young lions are broken."
- 7 ← Job 29:17 'Break their teeth in their mouth… the jaws (malte'ot) of the young lions': the same image (Eng. 58:6).
- 9 Job 3:16 "Like a hidden stillbirth (nefel) I would not be, like infants who never see light."
- 9 Eccl 6:3 "The stillborn is better off than he."
- 10 Eccl 7:6 "Like the crackling of thorns under a pot, so is the laughter of the fool."
- 11 Ps 68:24 "So that your foot may shatter them in blood."
- 11 Deut 32:43 "He avenges the blood of his servants and takes vengeance on his foes."
- 11 ← Job 22:19 'The upright will rejoice when he sees vengeance.'
- 12 Isa 3:10 "Say of the upright that it will be well, for they will eat the fruit of their deeds."
- 12 Gen 18:25 "Will not the judge of all the earth do justice?"