Proverbs 5
About this chapter
The chapter (checked in the WLC (WLC)). The prologue's first full warning against the woman who is a stranger, and its one praise of married love:
- Prov 5:1–6: her lips drip honey, her end is bitter. Her speech is sweet; her feet go down to death; she does not keep to the path of life.
- Prov 5:7–14: keep far from her door, or you will give your strength to strangers and groan at the end, saying, "How I hated discipline!" The young man's imagined confession is quoted (Prov 5:12–14).
- Prov 5:15–20: drink water from your own cistern. The images of cistern, well, spring and fountain stand for the young man's own wife; he is to rejoice in "the wife of your youth" and be lost in her love, not in a stranger's.
- Prov 5:21–23: Yahweh sees a man's ways; the wicked is caught by his own guilt and dies for lack of discipline.
The woman who is a stranger (D-2342). Here she is zarah, "the stranger" (Prov 5:3; Prov 5:20); the feminine is clear in the Hebrew, and "her" in the English. The plural zarim, "strangers," and the masculine nokhri, "an outsider" (Prov 5:10), are other men, who would take what belongs to the young man. See the Term note at Prov 2:16.
Sexual language (D-116; D-1321). The Hebrew of Prov 5:15–20 is figurative (water, springs) and then plain ("let her breasts satisfy you," Prov 5:19); the English is as plain as the Hebrew, no more and no less.
Layout (D-109b). Verse throughout. Prov 5:19 has 'oleh we-yored and atnaḥ and is set in three lines (checked).
Repetitions kept (Charter §5.6; checked): "pay attention… incline your ear" (Prov 5:1, as Prov 4:20); "lips" (Prov 5:2–3); "her feet… her steps" (Prov 5:5); "level" (palas, Prov 5:6; Prov 5:21, as Prov 4:26); "track(s)" (Prov 5:6; Prov 5:21); "And now, sons, listen to me" (Prov 5:7, again in Prov 7:24); "strangers" (Prov 5:10; Prov 5:17); "end" (aḥarit, Prov 5:4; Prov 5:11); "discipline… correction" (Prov 5:12; Prov 5:23); "water(s)" (Prov 5:15–16); "be lost" (shagah, Prov 5:19–20; Prov 5:23; D-1573); "embrace" (Prov 5:20, as Prov 4:8).
Divine names. YHWH once (Prov 5:21) (checked).
Verse numbering. Hebrew and English agree.
Notes
Lit "to keep discretions (mezimmot), and knowledge your lips will guard" (checked (WLC)). The plural mezimmot is "discretion" here, as the good sense of the word (D-1364; Prov 1:4). The change from infinitive to finite verb is the Hebrew's; the English keeps it. The lips that "guard knowledge" in this verse are set against the stranger's lips in the next (siftei zarah, Prov 5:3), a deliberate contrast [Widely held].
Zarah, "the stranger" (D-2342): the feminine adjective used alone, the ishah zarah of Prov 2:16. See the Term note there for the readings (another man's wife; a foreign woman; a symbol of folly).
"Drip honey… smoother than oil." Nofet is honey from the comb (Ps 19:11, checked (WLC)); the same words describe the bride's lips in Song 4:11 (checked). Sweet lips and a smooth palate are seductive speech (the "smooth sayings" of Prov 2:16; Prov 7:21) and, some think, kisses as well [Debated]. Ḥekh, "palate," is the organ of speech (Prov 8:7).
Lit "sharp as a sword of mouths (pifiyyot)" (checked (WLC)): a sword with two edges, each called a "mouth" because it "eats" (Judg 3:16, "a sword with two mouths," checked). "Two-edged" is the English idiom.
"Her end" (aḥaritah): what she leads to at last, or what she is at last; the word returns in Prov 5:11, "at your end." La'anah, "wormwood" (OSHB 3939), is a bitter plant, paired with poison in Deut 29:17 and Amos 6:12 (checked).
"Sheol" without the gloss, which was given at its first occurrence in the book (Prov 1:12; D-1320). "Take hold of" renders yitmokhu (tamakh, OSHB 8551), the verb of Prov 3:18 ("those who hold her fast" of wisdom) and Prov 4:4 ("hold fast my words") (checked (WLC)): the stranger's steps hold fast to Sheol as the son should hold fast to wisdom.
A difficult verse (checked (WLC)). Lit "The path of life, lest (pen) she level (tefalles); her tracks wander, (and) she does not know (lo teda')." Problems and readings [Debated; Unverified: the proposals from memory]:
- Pen, "lest," normally introduces a negative purpose. Here it is often taken as a strong negative ("she does not level / consider the path of life"), or the verse is read "lest you level the path of life," with the son as subject.
- Tefalles and teda' can be third person feminine ("she") or second person masculine ("you"). "She does not level… she does not know" keeps the stranger as subject throughout, as Prov 5:5 does; "lest you consider the path of life… you do not know" makes the verse a warning to the son.
- Palas is "level, make smooth" or "weigh, consider" (see Prov 4:26); "level" keeps one English verb in Prov 4:26, Prov 5:6 and Prov 5:21.
The English takes the stranger as subject and the plainest sense of each word; the alternatives are real.
Hodekha, "your vigor" (hod, OSHB 1935, "splendor, majesty, vigor"). Of a person it is the fresh strength of youth or his dignity [Debated]; with "your years" in parallel and "your strength" in Prov 5:10, the loss is of youth, strength and wealth to the woman's household or to her husband (checked (WLC)). Akhzari, "someone cruel" (OSHB 394): the cruel one may be the woman's husband, who takes his revenge (Prov 6:34–35), or the creditors and slave-owners who take a ruined man [Debated; Unverified].
Qahal we-'edah, "the assembly and the community" (OSHB 6951, 5712), the words of the Torah for Israel gathered as a people and as a court (Num 35:24, checked (WLC)); the renderings follow the earlier books' usage. The young man's ruin is public: he was nearly condemned, perhaps to death, by the gathered community as an adulterer (Lev 20:10) [Debated; Unverified], or he became a public disgrace.
"I was almost in utter ruin." Lit "Like a little, I was in all evil" (ki-m'at hayiti be-khol ra'): "I was nearly in total disaster" (ra' by sense, registry ra.md). The closing quotation mark ends the confession of Prov 5:12–14.
The water images (checked (WLC)). Cistern, well, springs, streams and fountain (Prov 5:15–18) stand for the young man's wife and his sexual life with her: "rejoice in the wife of your youth" (Prov 5:18) makes the meaning plain. The Song of Songs uses the same images of the bride ("a spring locked, a fountain sealed," Song 4:12; "a well of living water," Song 4:15, checked). Water in a dry land is private property and a family's life; to drink from another's well is theft [Widely held]. The English keeps the images and adds nothing (D-116).
Question or statement? The Hebrew has no question marker (checked (WLC)): Lit "Let your springs be scattered outside, streams of water in the squares." Readings [Debated; Unverified: proponents from memory]:
- a rhetorical question ("Should your springs be scattered…?"), expecting "no": the man's sexual strength should not be spent on other women; Prov 5:17 then answers, "Let them be for you alone." This is the most common reading, and the English follows it.
- a statement or wish: "your springs will overflow outside," i.e. your offspring will be many and fill the streets, a blessing; or the wife's waters should not go to others.
- some Greek manuscripts are reported to have a negative, "let not your waters be scattered" [Unverified; needs the Greek in an edition].
Plain language (D-116). Dadeha yerawwukha be-khol 'et, "let her breasts satisfy (Lit 'saturate') you at all times" (checked (WLC)): the Hebrew is plain, and so is the English. Dad "breast" (OSHB 1717) occurs also in Ezek 23:3 and Ezek 23:8 (checked). The Greek is reported to read "let her (love) lead you," as if from dodeha "her love" [Debated; Unverified]. The MT is translated.
"A loving doe, a graceful mountain goat." Ayyelet ahavim (Lit "a doe of loves") and ya'alat ḥen (Lit "a mountain goat of grace"; D-1572): images of beauty and agility, praise of the wife [Widely held]. The verse is set in three lines by its accents ('oleh we-yored on "mountain goat," atnaḥ on "at all times"; checked).
"Be lost in her love." Tishgeh (shagah, OSHB 7686) is "go astray, stray, reel" (as from drink, Isa 28:7, checked). The verb returns in Prov 5:20 ("why should you be lost, my son, in a stranger?") and Prov 5:23 ("in the greatness of his foolishness he is lost"): the same verb names delight in one's wife, straying with the stranger, and ruin. "Be lost (in)" keeps one English verb for all three (D-1573; Charter §5.6). Ahavah, "love," is erotic here, and the context says so (D-1330; registry love.md). Tamid, "always" (D-1304, not a ritual context).
The reason given (checked (WLC)): what the young man does in secret is "before the eyes of Yahweh." He "levels" a man's tracks (mefalles, the verb of Prov 4:26 and Prov 5:6): either he lays out a man's paths (and so knows them) or he weighs them Debated: see the note at [Prov 4:26]. "Levels" keeps the verb.
Lit "His guilts will capture him, the wicked, and in the cords of his wrongdoing he will be held fast" (checked (WLC)). 'Avonotav, "his guilt" (D-138: 'avon is guilt or punishment; here the guilt that becomes its own punishment, the other sense in this note); ḥatta'to, "his wrongdoing" (D-139). The wicked man's own deeds are the trap and the cords.
"Him, the wicked man." The object is named twice, by a suffix ("capture him") and by a noun (et ha-rasha'). Some scholars delete et ha-rasha' as an added explanation [Debated; Unverified]; the OSHB markup notes a Masoretic irregularity at this place ("unexpected reading," checked). The English keeps both, as the Hebrew does.
Cross-references
- 3 Song 4:11 'Your lips drip honey from the comb (nofet), bride': the same image in praise of the bride.
- 3 ← Prov 2:16 'The lips of the stranger drip honey, and her palate is smoother than oil'.
- 3 ← Ps 55:22 "Her palate is smoother than oil, but in the end she is bitter as wormwood, sharp as a two-edged sword."
- 4 ← Eccl 7:26 The strange woman: 'her end is bitter as wormwood'.
- 5 Prov 7:27 'Her house is the ways to Sheol, going down to the chambers of death'.
- 6 ← Prov 30:20 The ways of the woman who is a stranger 'wander, and she does not know it'.
- 7 Prov 7:24 Repeated half-verse: 'And now, sons, listen to me'.
- 7 Prov 8:32 Repeated half-verse: 'And now, sons, listen to me'.
- 15 Song 4:15 The bride as 'a fountain of gardens, a well of living water, and streams (nozlim) from Lebanon'.
- 15 ← Prov 9:17 'Drink water from your own cistern': the young man's own water against stolen water.
- 15 ← Song 4:12 'Drink water from your own cistern, flowing water (nozelim) from within your own well': the wife as a well.
- 18 Mal 2:14 'The wife of your youth… your companion and the wife of your covenant'.
- 18 ← Eccl 9:9 'Rejoice in the wife of your youth'.
- 19 Song 2:9 The lover compared to a gazelle and a young stag: the same animal imagery of desire.
- 19 ← Prov 7:18 'Let her breasts satisfy you (yerawwukha)': the same verb, of the young man's wife.
- 21 ← Job 34:21 'A man's ways are before the eyes of Yahweh, and he levels all his tracks.'
- 21 ← Prov 15:3 'For a man's ways are before the eyes of Yahweh'.