Philemon
Introduction to Philemon
Philemon: Introduction
Status: Draft · 2026-11-13
Labels:
- [Known]: established by physical or textual evidence
- [Widely held]: the consensus of critical scholarship
- [Traditional]: held by Jewish and/or Christian tradition
- [Debated]: no consensus
Philemon is the shortest of Paul's letters: 25 verses and 334 words in the SBLGNT [Known: counted]. Paul, in prison, writes to Philemon, to the assembly that meets in his house, and to two others, about Onesimus, a slave of Philemon's who has become a believer through Paul and whom Paul is sending back. It is the only letter in the NT that is mainly about a slave.
How this page was checked. Greek wording, counts and edition differences were checked with scripts/grk.py in the SBLGNT (v1.2) and STEPBible TAGNT. No papyrus, codex, Roman legal text, ancient letter or church writer was read; claims about them and about scholars are marked unverified in the source. No work on Philemon is in the project bibliography.
The proposals of this introduction are Q-2572 to Q-2576 in REVIEW-QUEUE.md. The one-chapter book is cited by verse as Phlm 1:16.
Name, author and date
- Title: Pros Philēmona, "To Philemon," from the first addressee (Phlm 1:1) [Known: checked].
- Author: Paul, "a prisoner of Christ Jesus," with Timothy (Phlm 1:1); Paul writes "with my own hand" at least the promise to repay (Phlm 1:19) [Known: checked]. Authorship is not disputed [Widely held].
- Date and place [Debated]: from an imprisonment, in Ephesus (about 54–55 CE; nearer to Colossae, which suits Paul's request for a guest room, Phlm 1:22) or in Rome (about 60–62) [Debated].
- Setting: the letter itself names no city. Colossians names Onesimus "one of you" (Col 4:9) and greets Archippus (Col 4:17), which places Philemon's household at Colossae [Widely held], whether or not Colossians is Paul's (see the Colossians introduction).
Language and style
- A personal letter in the Greek form: address, thanksgiving, request, promises, greetings [Widely held]. It is carefully composed, with repetition and wordplay (Q-2573; Q-2574) [Known for the features below].
- Splanchna, literally "inward parts," the seat of the feelings, three times: the hearts of the holy ones refreshed by Philemon (Phlm 1:7), Onesimus as "my very heart" (Phlm 1:12), "refresh my heart" (Phlm 1:20) [Known: checked]. The repetition of "refresh… heart" (7, 20) frames the request.
- Commercial language: "charge it to my account" (elloga, Phlm 1:18), "I will repay" (apotisō, Phlm 1:19), "you owe me even your own self" (prosopheileis, 1:19) [Known: checked]. Apotinō and prosopheilō occur nowhere else in the NT [Known: counted]. The form of 1:19 resembles a promissory note in papyrus documents [Widely held; Unverified].
Structure
| Verses | Content |
|---|---|
| Phlm 1:1–3 | Address: Philemon, Apphia "the sister," Archippus, and "the assembly at your house" |
| Phlm 1:4–7 | Thanksgiving for Philemon's love and trust |
| Phlm 1:8–20 | The request: "I appeal to you for my child, whom I fathered in my chains, Onesimus" |
| Phlm 1:21–22 | Confidence; "prepare a guest room for me" |
| Phlm 1:23–25 | Greetings (Epaphras, Mark, Aristarchus, Demas, Luke); blessing |
Original audience
- Addressees: Philemon, "our dear friend and co-worker"; Apphia "the sister"; Archippus "our fellow soldier"; and the assembly that meets in "your" (singular) house (Phlm 1:1–2) [Known: checked]. The singular "you" runs through the request, so the letter is to one person, read in front of the assembly [Widely held]. Who "you" is (Philemon, or Archippus, as J. Knox argued) is Debated; Philemon is the usual answer.
- Onesimus: a slave (doulos, Phlm 1:16) of the addressee; "once useless to you, but now is useful to you and to me" (Phlm 1:11); "separated from you for a while" (Phlm 1:15); he may have wronged or owed Philemon (Phlm 1:18) [Known: checked]. The letter never says that he ran away.
Slavery in the Roman world
- The institution [Widely held]: slaves were property under Roman law; a large share of the population of Roman cities were slaves or freed slaves; slaves worked in every occupation, from field labor to household management, medicine and secretarial work; they could be beaten, sold, separated from their families and sexually used; freeing (manumission) was common in cities, often around the age of 30, and the freed person remained bound to the former owner as patron.
- Runaways [Widely held]: a runaway slave (fugitivus) could be hunted, branded and punished; anyone harboring him was liable to the owner. Roman jurists distinguished a fugitive from a slave who left to seek an advocate (amicus domini, a friend of the master) to intercede in a dispute, who was not counted a fugitive.
- A parallel letter: Pliny the Younger wrote to his friend Sabinianus asking forgiveness for a freedman who had offended him (Letters 9.21), and thanked him afterward (9.24) [Widely held as a parallel].
Key cruxes
What happened to Onesimus? [Debated]
- The runaway reading [Traditional; long the majority view]: Onesimus ran away, perhaps having stolen (1:18), met Paul in prison, was converted, and is now sent back. Found in John Chrysostom's homilies on the letter [Traditional; Unverified].
- The intercession reading [Debated; widely followed since Lampe 1985]: Onesimus, in trouble with his master, deliberately sought out Paul, a friend of the master, to plead for him (the amicus domini category), so he was not legally a fugitive.
- Sent by the household [Debated]: the assembly or Philemon sent Onesimus to serve Paul in prison (compare Epaphroditus in Phil 2:25), and Paul asks to keep him (Knox; S. Winter).
- Not a slave at all [Debated; a minority]: A. D. Callahan (1993) argues that Onesimus was Philemon's estranged brother, "both in the flesh and in the Lord" (Phlm 1:16), and that "as a slave" is a comparison. Most scholars hold that doulos here is literal [Widely held].
- The text: "perhaps this is why he was separated (echōristhē, passive) for a while, so that you might have him back forever, no longer as a slave but more than a slave, a dear brother" (Phlm 1:15–16) [Known: checked]. The passive may hint at God's purpose [Widely held]. ReScript policy (Q-2576): the text says "was separated," never "ran away."
What does Paul ask? (Phlm 1:13–21) [Debated]
- Paul would have liked to keep Onesimus "so that he might serve me on your behalf" (1:13) but did nothing without consent (1:14); he asks Philemon to "receive him as you would me" (1:17), to charge any debt to Paul (1:18), and says "you will do even more than I say" (1:21) [Known: checked].
- Readings: a request for forgiveness and a welcome only; a hint that Onesimus should be returned to Paul for the work; a request, put as tactfully as possible, for manumission ("more than I say") [Debated]. "No longer as a slave" (Phlm 1:16) can mean a change of status or a change in how Philemon regards him, "both in the flesh and in the Lord" [Debated].
- What the letter does not do [Known for the text]: it does not condemn slavery as such, and it does not command manumission. Compare the instruction to slaves in 1 Cor 7:21, whose meaning ("make use of it," freedom or slavery) is itself Debated.
Reception in the slavery debates [Known that these uses occurred; details unverified]
- Defenders of slavery in the United States and elsewhere cited Philemon as apostolic sanction for returning fugitive slaves to their owners (it was called the "Pauline mandate" in support of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850) [Widely held].
- Abolitionists answered from Phlm 1:16 ("no longer as a slave… a dear brother") that Paul's principle undermined slavery, and some argued that Onesimus was not a slave at all [Widely held].
- African American interpreters have read the letter in both directions, as a text of the slaveholders' Bible and as a text of brotherhood (Callahan; the volume Onesimus Our Brother, 2012) [Widely held].
- Later tradition: a bishop of Ephesus named Onesimus is mentioned by Ignatius (To the Ephesians 1.3), and J. Knox identified him with the slave of this letter, as the collector of Paul's letters [Debated; a speculative hypothesis].
- ReScript policy: these are later readings, reported in notes labeled Traditional or Debated. The translation renders the Greek without making Paul either more or less critical of slavery than the text is (Charter §2a.4): doulos is "slave" (D-3316).
The text
- Base text: SBLGNT, printed and numbered; where it stands alone against NA28 and the Tyndale House GNT agreeing, ReScript translates the reading of those two editions, with a Text note (D-201, settled 2026-11-13). TAGNT records no such place in Philemon [Known: checked].
- Manuscripts [Widely held; not checked]: P87 (3rd century, a fragment of 13–15, 24–25) is the earliest; P61; the codices ℵ, A, C, D and others; P46 as preserved does not contain Philemon [Widely held].
- TAGNT differences [Known: checked with
grk.py variants]: Phlm 1:2 "Apphia the sister" (critical editions) or "the beloved" (TR, Byzantine); Phlm 1:6 "in us" or "in you" (TR); Phlm 1:12: TR and Byzantine add "so receive him." Text notes where the meaning changes. - Phlm 1:9: presbytēs "an old man" in all editions; R. Bentley and J. B. Lightfoot proposed reading presbeutēs "ambassador" (compare Eph 6:20, presbeuō) (Q-2574) [Debated].
- Departures: none proposed.
Translation issues and notes for this book
NT-wide items applied as written: Q-2473 kyrios; D-3319 Christos; Q-2483 pistis; Q-2486 charis; Q-2495 "the assembly at your house"; D-3316 doulos "slave" (Phlm 1:16, twice); Q-2506 adelphos / adelphē (Apphia "the sister," Phlm 1:2; Onesimus "a dear brother," 1:16); Q-2508 sarx ("in the flesh," 1:16).
| Item | Topic | Proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Q-2572 | Phlm 1:16 | "no longer as a slave but more than a slave, a dear brother," literal (SIGNIFICANT) |
| Q-2573 | the Onesimus puns (1:11; 1:20) | "useless… useful"; "let me have some benefit from you," notes on the name |
| Q-2574 | presbytēs (Phlm 1:9) | "an old man," note on "ambassador" |
| Q-2575 | splanchna | "heart" all three times, Lit note "inward parts" |
| Q-2576 | echōristhē (Phlm 1:15) | "was separated," never "ran away" (SIGNIFICANT) |
Sources
Primary texts read: SBLGNT (v1.2) and STEPBible TAGNT (CC BY 4.0), in sources/greek.
Proposed sources (not added to bibliography.toml; none read):
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Letter to Philemon (Anchor Bible 34C; New York: Doubleday, 2000)
- P. Lampe, "Keine 'Sklavenflucht' des Onesimus," Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft 76 (1985): 135–137
- B. M. Rapske, "The Prisoner Paul in the Eyes of Onesimus," New Testament Studies 37 (1991): 187–203
- A. D. Callahan, "Paul's Epistle to Philemon: Toward an Alternative Argumentum," Harvard Theological Review 86 (1993): 357–376
- J. Knox, Philemon among the Letters of Paul (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1935; rev. 1959)
- J. A. Glancy, Slavery in Early Christianity (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002)
- J. A. Harrill, Slaves in the New Testament (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2006)
- M. G. Johnson, J. A. Noel and D. K. Williams (eds.), Onesimus Our Brother (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012)
To verify before publication: every claim marked unverified; the Roman legal texts on fugitives and the amicus domini; Pliny, Letters 9.21; Chrysostom's homilies; the 19th-century American uses of the letter; P87.